I grade my reviews on a five flame scale:

  • 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 = fire

  • 🔥🔥🔥🔥 = pretty good

  • 🔥🔥🔥 = okay

  • 🔥🔥 = pretty bad

  • 🔥 = hot garbage

Head on over to the Top Picks section to see my favorites!


Daddy Issues: A Memoir

Daddy Issues: A Memoir

If you enjoyed this review, please consider purchasing this book from my Amazon Associates link (applies to Kindle purchases as well): https://link.amazon/B00qWz837. The commissions I receive from your purchase help pay for the costs of running this website. Thanks for your support!


Do you want to be part of the zeitgeist or not?? You don’t have to be an OG Call Her Daddy listener to know about Alex Cooper and Sofia Franklyn’s fallout. Not to brag, but I *was* an OG Call Her Daddy listener (I played an episode for Devin during a cross-country road trip, the two most unbelievably crass girls playing as the soundtrack to our drive up Going-to-the-Sun Road, Devin visibly disgusted). I liked their chemistry, and while I found them ridiculous, I also, more importantly, found them funny. When the show broke up in May of 2020, Alex immediately came out on top with a clear, believable narrative: Sofia was a greedy and lazy girl who was being manipulated by her boyfriend and deserved to be ousted. I bought it, even though I liked Sofia more, because these two girls acted certifiably insane on a weekly basis, so I wasn’t shocked to hear that one of them had done something certifiably insane.

Welp, Sofia lay in the cut like a lioness, waiting six long years before upending this narrative, and boy, does she come with receipts. She drops shocking bombshells on every page, and nothing is off limits, from her unstable, drug-fueled upbringing to her entire Call Her Daddy experience. Perhaps the most shocking piece of it all is how impressive the writing is. I was completely blown away by her writing skills. I knew the chick with the vocal fry was funnier than people gave her credit for, but I didn’t know that she could perfectly combine the conversational voice that listeners are used to with vivid, heart-wrenching imagery. I had my pen at the ready, annotating left and right as if it was prize-winning poetry. She knew that she had a treasure in her hands, and she trusted herself to communicate it effectively. Alex Cooper and her husband Matt Kaplan are powerful people who control many levers in a powerful industry. Because of that, Sofia had to be very careful. Yes, she wove a delicate dance, but perhaps I gave her a little too much credit. I sent a few screenshots of the text to my Toasters group chat and was confused why the images they received were completely blurred out, like television static. Well, of course, Sofia thought of everything! There must be some watermark on each page to prevent people with advanced copies from sharing spoilers and keep Matt Kaplan from preemptively discrediting her work. No, girly, calm down. I eventually realized that for whatever reason, whenever I mark up a photo with highlights, my phone sends a distorted image. Take it up with Apple. 

So, I’m impressed with Sofia’s writing and her patience, and unimpressed with my lack of critical thinking skills. At the time of the fallout, I remember wondering why she wasn’t sticking up for herself more. Speak, woman! But it’s clear that if she had come out swinging, she would have read as petty and reactive. Alex’s swift and polished narrative would prevail. Moreover, this was peak Covid, and everyone was chronically online. The pile-on was honestly disgusting. After only knowing Alex’s side of the story, there was an overnight shift whereby Sofia wasn’t just lazy and greedy; she should be hated and publicly hung. I never participated in the pile-on, which makes me a better person than all of you! But of course Sofia was silent. She went from being on top of the world as the number one podcaster to getting death threats and questioning her entire existence.

Without getting into spoiler territory, here are my broad takeaways. There are likely two truths: Alex was a back-stabbing liar willing to throw anyone under the bus, and Sofia was probably a nightmare co-worker. They both had different perceptions of their relationship and the value that they individually brought to the show, but zooming out, Alex comes across as not a good person. Sofia owns all of her own messiness and takes accountability for her faults, but Alex’s consistent willingness to use and then discard people (not just Sofia) is icky. After reading the book, I unfollowed the Call Her Daddy, Unwell network, and Alex Cooper’s accounts. Not all heroes wear capes!

Unlike Alex, one person who surprisingly comes across in a positive light is Dave Portnoy. I don’t think that was Sofia’s intention, but it’s a testament to her telling the story as thoroughly and honestly as she can. Despite Dave’s naturally intimidating demeanor, his frankness also makes him a good boss. You know what you’re getting from the jump. He also gives his employees a lot of creative freedom (although working in the Barstool office seems like a testosterone-filled nightmare). The dynamic with Dave also contains multiple truths. Dave plucked them out of obscurity and took a chance on them, so their original contract was ass. Then, their rise was unprecedentedly meteoric. Those original contracts seemed patently insane. But Dave prizes loyalty, and there’s something to be said for not biting the hand that feeds you. But then it reaches a certain level of exploitation and unreasonableness. This is LAYERED, SHEEPLE! My favorite little podcast, The Toast, did an excellent, Barbara Walters-esque interview of Dave last week that I highly recommend.

So, this whole thing is majorly juicy, and I slurped it up in a hot second, but I do have some minor complaints. For instance, she doesn’t bookend some of her stories. The pacing is super quick, which I think contributed to the comedic element of the book, where she makes hilarious throwaway jabs and then completely moves on; however, there are plenty of spots in the book that feel unresolved. They’re mostly unimportant loose ends, like an incomplete story about a drunken night on the town (how did she get her stuff back??). Then, there are bigger-ticket items. For example, Alex Cooper talks about sexual harassment in her Hulu documentary, and sexual harassment plays a broader role in the whole Call Her Daddy fallout, so Alex’s experience is particularly pertinent. Given Sofia’s thoroughness, why wasn’t this touched on in the book? Did Alex not discuss it with her, another example of her keeping her cards close to her chest as a manipulation tactic, or did Sofia choose to omit this element? Understandably, this is a big sticking point for Dave, and I wish Sofia had unpacked it more. On the other hand, her details about Suitman, the alias for her boyfriend at the time, seem too intimate. One of my biggest takeaways is JUSTICE FOR SUITMAN, so her over-sharing seems like an undeserved twist of the knife. I don’t think that’s intentional– she’s open in interviews about her appreciation and sympathy for him– but maybe some things should stay sacred? I want to give the man a hug.

Okay, I could truly talk about this book for hours. I feel like a proud mom–happy that Sofia gets to say her piece and get some peace. I don’t think that I would feel so passionately about the book if it weren’t for her raw and poignant writing. She’s impressively nonchalant, witty, and self-aware, a trifecta that I didn’t know I needed. The book scratched an itch for me– a full-circle moment for Daddy Gang; however, you can definitely read this and enjoy it even if you didn’t listen to the pod. At its core, it’s a heart-breaking story of the dissolution of deep friendship. It also has a practical appeal, intertwining finances with morality (how do you feel about them trying to break their contract; what are the implications for other shows, like Chicks in the Office, etc.). And who doesn’t love some debaucherous NYC nightlife stories? Daddy Issues: A Memoir receives 5 out of 5 flames.

Cleopatra and Frankenstein

Cleopatra and Frankenstein